Fields of law in German, European and international inheritance law

Which right decides on the heirs, which on the ownership of a house and which on the tax? The following eight areas of law show, on the basis of concrete cases, how these questions play together in a succession in Germany and across national borders.

Directly to the area of law
Wills and contracts of inheritance · Family and compulsory share · Jurisdiction and status of succession · Proof of succession · Third countries · Liability and proceedings · Business succession · Taxation

Symbolic image of a family business before the company transfer

Testament, treaty of inheritance and international form

The design begins with the question of who should receive the heir status and who should only demand a certain object. When moving abroad, the disposition must also remain readable and usable there. For the form of a will, the Hague Convention opens several connections, for example to the place of establishment or nationality. Whether those in possession were able to commit themselves to content is to be examined separately.

A will signed in Cologne is presented in France

A German couple moves to Lyon. After the first death, the children consider the communal will invalid because of the move. First, it is necessary to determine when and where both were signed and what nationalities they had at that time. Subsequently, for each arrangement it is to be clarified whether it binds and whether a later letter from the survivor could change it at all.

Design of wills · 1961 Hague Convention

Legal succession, matrimonial property law and compulsory share

Before calculating a hereditary quota, determine what belonged to the deceased. In the case of international marriages, different legal systems may apply to property regimes and succession. For European property law, the participation of states as well as marriage and legal choice dates are important. The law applicable to the succession generally also covers compulsory parts and other restrictions on the freedom to test.

The widow and a daughter claim the same house

Both spouses are in the land register, in the will the widow is mentioned as the sole heir. The daughter calculates her compulsory share from the full house value. Prior to any quantification, ownership shares, property regimes, succession statutes and estate liabilities must be clarified. Only then can it be decided whether a monetary claim exists and which value serves as a starting point.

Compulsory share under German law · EU Marriage Property Regulation

Jurisdiction and applicable law of succession

For succession from 17 onwards. In August 2015, the EU inheritance law regulation in the participating states basically links to the last habitual residence. Jurisdiction and hereditary status are two independent questions. A person may choose the law of a State whose nationality he possesses at election or on death. The choice of law alone does not automatically transfer the proceedings to the courts of that State.

German Testament at the last point of life in Spain

The deceased lived in Valencia for years and had explicitly chosen German inheritance law. The heirs cannot derive any jurisdiction from this from the court in Hanover. They document the last point of life and check separately whether the requirements for a choice of court agreement or another reason for jurisdiction exist.

European succession · EU inheritance law regulation, in particular art. 4–7 and 20–23

Certificate of Inheritance, Certificate of Succession and Real Estate Register

Heirs, legatees with immediate rights, executors of wills and estate administrators may need proof depending on the task. The European Certificate of Succession shall facilitate proof in participating Member States. The information required by a register for registration shall also be determined in accordance with the respective register law.

An heiress wants to rewrite an apartment in Italy

The daughter already has the death certificate and the opened will. At the register, it asks what proof is needed for the heir and how the object must be identified. For example, the application for the certificate of succession may contain the necessary information. Translation, validity of the certified copy and local form of submission must be clarified before the date.

European Certificate of Succession · Succession in Italy · Art. 62-73 EU inheritance law regulation

Third countries, treaties and division of successions

From the point of view of a participating EU state, the law of a third country can also be invoked. Then there is a possible remittance or referral by type. 34 and, where applicable, priority treaties of the State in accordance with art. 75 to be tested. The third country in turn applies its own private international law. The legal allocation of movable property and real estate can thus fall apart.

An account and a property belong to the same Turkish-German estate

A Turkish citizen leaves his children a German bank account and an apartment in Hanover. For both assets, the scope of the German-Turkish estate agreement must be examined. A bank information on the proof of inheritance accepted for the account does not yet answer the question of the Land Registry. The children therefore prepare both requests separately.

German-Turkish heritage · Other third country cases · Art. 34 and 75 EU inheritance law regulations

Community of heirs, liability and proceedings

Who enters into rights and obligations of the deceased and stand as heirs for debts, is basically based on the status of inheritance. For insolvency proceedings, foreclosure and individual procedural acts, there are additional rules. In the case of an over-indebted estate, deadlines and achievable safeguarding measures must be examined in parallel with the investigation of assets.

The siblings discover a foreign loan agreement after death

The bank demands the entire remaining debt from the sister living in Hanover. The brothers and sisters have three questions. Was the claim on the day of death, is the sister personally liable, and is there already an enforceable title? They secure the contract, payment plan and proof of delivery and have checked which deadline for their response.

Liability of heirs · Community of co-heirs · Art. 23 EU inheritance law regulation

Business succession and company law

In the case of a family business, succession, social contractual succession clauses and power of representation must be examined separately. The EU Inheritance Law Regulation explicitly excludes company law issues such as statutory clauses on the fate of shares upon the death of a shareholder. The will must therefore be adapted to the concrete social contract.

Inherit two children, according to the statutes only one may follow

The children consider themselves jointly entitled to vote after the opening of the will. Before the next general meeting, they shall examine the statutes in force on death, the legal form and the law applicable to the company. This results in who can exercise membership rights and whether the other family branch may have a severance pay entitlement.

Business succession · Art. 1 par. 2 letter h EU inheritance law regulation

Inheritance tax and cross-border taxation

Taxation follows its own national rules. Residence, nationality and type of property may have a different meaning than for the status of succession. In the case of charges in two countries, the relevant double taxation agreement and, as far as applicable, the requirements for crediting according to § 21 ErbStG shall be examined.

Two financial authorities record the same holiday home

The heiress receives a tax assessment abroad and is also to declare the acquisition in Germany. For a possible relief, it assigns the foreign decision to the specific acquisition, documents the payment and breaks down taxable value and tax according to assets. A registration fee levied abroad is to be assessed differently than a tax corresponding to the inheritance tax.

Inheritance tax · § 21 ErbStG