Anyone who transfers a property to a child during their lifetime and receives a lifelong annuity for this purpose can in principle trigger the ten-year period for compulsory share supplementary rights. The Federal Court of Justice has ruled that an annuity secured by a real load does not automatically lead to the transferor retaining the economic enjoyment of the property. The decisive factor is which rights of use are actually retained.
Transfer of real estate against a lifetime annuity
In the case decided by the Federal Court of Justice, a mother had already transferred several properties to her son in 1995. One of them was built with a rented residential building.
In return, the son undertook to pay his mother a monthly pension of DM 1,500. The pension payment was secured by a real load on the transferred property. The basis for the agreed payment was, among other things, the rental income from the residential building.
In 2013, the mother waived the further payment of the body pension and approved the cancellation of the real load. She passed away in 2021.
After her death, the daughter demanded from the testamentary sole heir, her brother, among other things, the evaluation of the transferred land. It took the view that the ten-year period for compulsory share supplementary rights had not started initially because of the agreed pension.
BGH: Leibrente is not a reserved right of use
The Federal Court of Justice gave the defendant son with judgment of 24. June 2026 (Az.) IV ZR 141/25) law.
According to § 2325 Abs. 3 sentence 2 BGB, a donation shall in principle not be taken into account when calculating the compulsory share supplement entitlement if ten years have elapsed since the performance of the gifted item. The condition for the commencement of the period is that the deceased has actually separated the object from his property and abandoned the essential economic enjoyment in it.
A comprehensive usufruct reservation can prevent the start of the deadline, for example, because the transferor continues to claim the essential uses of the property for himself.
However, an annuity must be judged differently. According to the BGH, the promise of a lifetime pension does not lead to the former owner continuing to use the property legally. This also applies if the pension amount is based on the rental income of the transferred property.
Even the agreed real load did not change this. It serves only to secure the pension entitlement in rem. It gives the entitled person the opportunity to satisfy himself from the property in the event of a failure to pay. On the other hand, it does not confer a right of its own to use the property or directly collect the proceeds thereof.
Thus, the ten-year period began in the decided case already with the registration of the transfer of ownership in the land register on 7 November. March 1996. It therefore expired in March 2006.
Subsequent waiver of an annuity shall be considered separately.
Another important question concerned the mother’s subsequent waiver of outstanding pension payments in 2013.
The BGH clarified that this waiver can also constitute a donation. Because by remission of future pension rights and the cancellation of the real load, the mother gave up her own asset legal position.
For this independent donation, the ten-year period began only with the waiver on 28. October 2013. She had not expired at the time of her mother’s death in 2021.
However, the applicant’s specific valuation requests were not aimed at this later waiver as an independent subject of the estate. Therefore, this circumstance did not lead to the success of the action in the final proceedings.
The decision thus shows that, in the case of a transfer of land against Leibrente, not only the original assignment contract but also subsequent changes to the agreed compensatory measures may be relevant under compulsory part-law.
Significance for the anticipated succession
The judgment is of considerable practical importance for the organisation of property succession during his lifetime. Anyone who wants to transfer real estate to children or other relatives should carefully consider the different design options and their legal consequences.
It is particularly important to distinguish between the following designs:
- Annuity: The transferee undertakes to make recurring payments to the transferor. In principle, such an obligation does not prevent the start of the deadline simply because it is covered by a real load.
- Utility: The transferor reserves the right to continue using the property or, for example, to obtain rental income. This may prevent the start of the 10-year period.
- Right of residence: Depending on the scope and actual design, a reserved right of residence can also have an impact on the start of the deadline.
- Right of recovery: Contractual rights for reversal or retransfer can affect the economic and legal valuation of the transfer.
A blanket equal treatment of these arrangements is not possible. The decisive factor is the specific contractual agreements and the actual powers remaining with the transferor.
Contract drafting decides on the start of the period
With its decision, the BGH strengthens the possibility of transferring real estate within the framework of the anticipated succession against agreement of an annuity without preventing the start of the ten-year period for compulsory share supplementary rights.
For practice, however, this does not mean that every transfer against an annuity automatically triggers the deadline immediately. The decisive factor remains whether the transferor has actually given up the substantial economic enjoyment of the property.
Anyone who wants to transfer assets already during their lifetime should therefore not consider an annuity, usufruct, housing right and recovery rights in isolation, but have their effects on compulsory share entitlements, pensions and the subsequent distribution of estate jointly examined.
This post was created using artificial intelligence. The contents serve for general information and do not replace individual legal advice.
Who will continue to receive maintenance from the estate in the first 30 days?
BGH: Leibrente does not prevent the beginning of the ten-year period in case of property transfer
Anyone who transfers a property to a child during their lifetime and receives a lifelong annuity...
The owner dies before the person entitled
What happens if the estate does not even cover the costs of the proceedings?
A private statement after the funeral
An internal exemption contract between siblings
Six case variants for practice
The mother stays alive
Case 1. A right of residence in rem can secure them.
The participants clarify which rooms may be used, who bears ongoing costs and major repairs and what happens with a permanent pull-out. In the case of a planned hedge, it must also be checked which rank the right is given over existing charges.
Parents continue to rent
Case 2. A usufruct can receive the yields.
In the handover agreement, it can be read who was allowed to purchase rentals, decide on use and bear loads. Actual implementation may be as important for economic evaluation as the designation of the reserved right.
The child is in bankruptcy
Case 3. Agreed recovery rights must be examined.
An asset status compares realizable values and mature claims. Uncertain claims are specifically reported. If there are concrete signs of insolvency or over-indebtedness, a possible need for action must be assessed immediately.
A sibling child should receive money
Case 4. Determine the maturity and funding.
The hereditary quota is distinguished from the allocation of individual objects. For an agreement, the outstanding debts and costs are first recorded and then takeover, compensation and execution are coordinated in a joint agreement.
Parents are poor
Case 5. Examine legal recovery.
The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.
The property is burdened
Case 6. Personal loan liability does not automatically pass.
Loan borrowers, backup providers and owners can be different people. At the date of death, residual debt, existing collateral and ongoing installments are determined. Only then can it be identified who the creditor can claim in which capacity.
