Compulsory share under German law

Descendants, spouses and, in certain circumstances, parents who are excluded from succession may have a monetary claim against the heir. The compulsory share is half the value of their statutory share. Siblings have no compulsory share of their own.

How is a disinherited child’s compulsory share calculated in Germany?

Start with the share the child would inherit by law. The compulsory share is half its value. If the statutory share is one half and the relevant net estate is €200,000, the claim is €50,000. Earlier gifts may require a separate calculation.

§ 2303 BGB · Lifetime gifts and the compulsory share

Who can demand a compulsory share and from whom?

First a legal comparison rate, then a net discount and supplementary donations. Monitor the limitation period separately. A simple payment request does not regularly inhibit them.

What makes a difference in individual cases

When calculating, do not start with the house value, but with the pedigree and the property status. Only from this does the legal comparison rate arise. After this, ownership shares, deductible debts and possible gift supplements are to be examined. A subsequent change in family assignment can change the whole bill.

Symbolic image for family estate planning

From quota to payment amount

For the first invoice, legal inheritance quota and actual value should be in separate columns. Before each assessment, it must be clarified who the property belonged to at death. In the case of a house kept together, only the proportion of the deceased should be included. Gifts from earlier years are again their own computing variable.

DocumentWhat can be clarified with it
Family Tree and Marriage ContractDetermining the legal comparative rate
Testaments, former treaties and waiversDetermining the economic status of the beneficiary
List of assets with dates of deathCalculate amount and report contested positions

Question on this subject · Inventory

Money claim, donation and economic value

The legal examination separates the allocation of assets from a possible monetary settlement. In the case of lifetime transfers, consideration, reserved rights and enforcement date shall be disclosed. An arrangement for crediting to the compulsory share and compensation among descendants have different prerequisites and can lead to different results.

In international succession cases, the status of inheritance also covers in principle compulsory share rights as well as the compensation and crediting of previous grants (Art.) 23, par. 2 letters h and i of the EU Heritage Regulation. Whether the property was effectively transferred during his lifetime can be governed by other regulations.

Interaction of legal areas at a glance · EU Marriage Property Regulation

Six examples from inheritance law practice

An only child is disinherited

Case 1. Determine the legal quota including spouses.

The invoice begins with the family constellation and the assets relevant for the comparison. The participants record the calculation path with fractions before converting into money. In this way, errors in quota and value can be identified separately.

A brother asks for a compulsory share

Case 2. Their own justification is missing.

The starting point is the marital status on the day of death and the statutory comparison rate. For quantification purposes, estate values, deductible liabilities and possible previous grants are recognised separately. In this way, it remains clear at which position the participants set different amounts.

Parents demand payment

Case 3. Consider priority of descendants.

The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.

A property is burdened

Case 4. Reconciling value and debt.

For the solution, ownership and encumbrances are taken at the relevant time. Anyone who owns the key or bears ongoing costs is not necessarily the owner. This distinction affects the value and possible dispositions.

The daughter received money in advance

Case 5. Checking credit.

For the assessment, the family circumstances on the relevant day and the full text of existing dispositions shall be recorded. Only from both can it be deduced in which legal position the family member can act or demand something.

Two heirs are liable

Case 6. Defendants and compensation.

The beneficiary of the compulsory share checks who he can use in an external relationship. How the burden is subsequently distributed among the several heirs must be accounted for separately.

Legal basis and advice

§ 2303 BGB · Addressing inheritance law