A gift can increase the compulsory share, even though the item is no longer in the estate at death. For the supplement, the compulsory share from the actual estate and the compulsory share are compared with the addition of the relevant gift value.
The next steps
The ten-year consideration presupposes a performance in the sense of § 2325 BGB. A fully reserved usufruct may prevent the start of the period. A special rule applies to benefits for spouses. The lowest value principle, a mixed donation and the crediting of own gifts of the person entitled can change the bill.
What makes a difference in individual cases
For each claimed gift, a separate timeline should be created. Contract conclusion, actual transfer of assets and subsequent abandonment of a reserved right may fall apart. Only then can the start of the deadline and possible meltdown be assessed. A uniform ten-year account for all grants can distort the result.

From quota to payment amount
For the first invoice, legal inheritance quota and actual value should be in separate columns. Before each assessment, it must be clarified who the property belonged to at death. In the case of a house kept together, only the proportion of the deceased should be included. Gifts from earlier years are again their own computing variable.
| Document | What can be clarified with it |
|---|---|
| Family Tree and Marriage Contract | Determining the legal comparative rate |
| Testaments, former treaties and waivers | Determining the economic status of the beneficiary |
| List of assets with dates of death | Calculate amount and report contested positions |
Question on this subject · Inventory
Money claim, donation and economic value
The legal examination separates the allocation of assets from a possible monetary settlement. In the case of lifetime transfers, consideration, reserved rights and enforcement date shall be disclosed. An arrangement for crediting to the compulsory share and compensation among descendants have different prerequisites and can lead to different results.
In international succession cases, the status of inheritance also covers in principle compulsory share rights as well as the compensation and crediting of previous grants (Art.) 23, par. 2 letters h and i of the EU Heritage Regulation. Whether the property was effectively transferred during his lifetime can be governed by other regulations.
Interaction of legal areas at a glance · EU Marriage Property Regulation
Six practical examples
A father gives away cash shortly before his death
Case 1. Enforcement and timing.
Donation promises, actual performance and any consideration are documented separately. It is important to know which asset advantage the beneficiary actually received and whether the participants had already agreed on a later crediting at the time of the grant.
A property goes to the daughter for a lifetime pension
Case 2. Separate pay and unpaid share.
The envisaged benefit shall be ranked by obligor, recipient, start and maturity. The economic classification must also take into account adjustment, protection and the consequences of a previous death of a person involved.
The transferor retains comprehensive usufruct
Case 3. Investigate economic enjoyment and start date.
In the handover agreement, it can be read who was allowed to purchase rentals, decide on use and bear loads. Actual implementation may be as important for economic evaluation as the designation of the reserved right.
The wife received the house many years ago
Case 4. Determine the date of dissolution of the marriage.
For the solution, ownership and encumbrances are taken at the relevant time. Anyone who owns the key or bears ongoing costs is not necessarily the owner. This distinction affects the value and possible dispositions.
The claimant also received money
Case 5. Examine own gift according to § 2327 BGB.
Donation promises, actual performance and any consideration are documented separately. It is important to know which asset advantage the beneficiary actually received and whether the participants had already agreed on a later crediting at the time of the grant.
The inheritance does not have to provide the supplement
Case 6. Under the conditions of § 2329 BGB, examine claims against gifted persons.
The daughter first clarifies to what extent the inheritance itself is obliged to supplement. Only for the remaining shortfall is it checked whether the donation to the recipient and his possible deprivation by payment meet the requirements.
