How is an undertaking assessed in the compulsory share dispute?

Praxisarchiv · April 2023 · Editorial processing November 2026

The income statement contains an unusually good individual year after a major order. For the company value, the question arises whether this profit was repeatable and what investments are necessary. The mandate to the expert should identify such points of contention before the parties only negotiate a final number.

Legal classification

For the calculation of the compulsory share, the stock and value of the estate in the case of inheritance count. In the case of a company, sustainable returns, risks, dependence on the owner and actual usability must be examined.

The value for a compulsory share entitlement, a company severance payment and a tax assessment can follow different requirements. The assignment to the evaluator shall specify the valuation question.

Six case variants

A practice loses its owner

Case 1. Evaluate portable customer base.

For a robust outcome, the measurement date and condition of the asset are determined. If the parties concerned differ in value, they should first compare the underlying data before negotiating the compensation amount.

A machine belongs privately to the decedent

Case 2. Delimited from operating assets.

The family determines whether the estate includes the holding itself, an interest in a company or an asset provided to private individuals. The appropriate evidence and the necessary cooperation of other stakeholders will depend on this.

A property is undervalued

Case 3. Investigate silent reserves.

For the solution, ownership and encumbrances are taken at the relevant time. Anyone who owns the key or bears ongoing costs is not necessarily the owner. This distinction affects the value and possible dispositions.

An important customer announces

Case 4. Determine the reference date.

For the assessment, it has to be clarified whether the termination was based on a new development only after the reference date or confirmed a customer loss that was already recognizable at the reference date. Contracts and correspondence separate both situations from each other.

The Contract Calls Book Value

Case 5. Check the applicability to severance pay.

A nominally identical payment can be economically different. For the negotiation, amount, maturity, interest and collateral are compared. In the case of an installment solution, the failure of a rate also belongs in the agreement.

A report counts debt twice

Case 6. Balance sheet and computing path reconcile.

The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.

Deepening: Company valuation

Related legal guide · Compulsory share under German law