Praxisarchiv · July 2021 · Editorial processing November 2026
In the transfer document, it only says “for the start”. Whether the money was a loan, a compensatory equipment or a gift can hardly be deduced from this alone. Simultaneous letters and subsequent interest or principal payments can significantly change the meaning of the note.
Legal classification
A pre-reception is not a uniform type of entitlement. Compensation under descendants and crediting to the compulsory share follow various rules.
Documents from the time of payment are particularly meaningful. A later memory does not replace a required simultaneous arrangement.
Six case variants
The father pays for a practice foundation
Case 1. Test equipment.
Decisive are the reason, scale and intention of parents in financing. A loan for setting up a practice is to be distinguished from free equipment for an independent living position.
“On your compulsory share” is in the contract
Case 2. § 2315 BGB.
The starting point is the marital status on the day of death and the statutory comparison rate. For quantification purposes, estate values, deductible liabilities and possible previous grants are recognised separately. In this way, it remains clear at which position the participants set different amounts.
The money was repayable
Case 3. Accounting for loans separately.
Loan borrowers, backup providers and owners can be different people. At the date of death, residual debt, existing collateral and ongoing installments are determined. Only then can it be identified who the creditor can claim in which capacity.
A brother was given care
Case 4. Clarify the purpose.
The services actually provided and their recipient are documented. For the case solution, a distinction must be made between whether money from the estate is claimed, a contract should be fulfilled or a social security provider examines its own requirements.
The siblings were given equal amounts
Case 5. Compare time and value.
The hereditary quota is distinguished from the allocation of individual objects. For an agreement, the outstanding debts and costs are first recorded and then takeover, compensation and execution are coordinated in a joint agreement.
A listing is made after death
Case 6. Complete original documents.
The location and condition of the document shall be documented. The full text, including the envelope or annexes, may be more important for classification than a partial copy already made.
Related legal guide · Donation
