In the case of a donation, the parties concerned agree on gratuitousness. In the estate, it is often disputed whether a payment was given, borrowed or made as an advance on a claim.
Gift or loans – what can the heirs demand back?
Remittance purpose, messages and later repayments can prove the former will. compulsory share addition and tax consequences must also be examined.
What makes a difference in individual cases
If a request for restitution arises only after death, statements from the donor are often missing. Messages about repayment, a repayment plan or recurring transfers are then especially valuable. Purpose notes such as “help” or “for you” should be read in connection with the entire agreement at that time.

Checking the transfer contract on the basis of everyday life
Work through the agreed services in time order. What does the beneficiary receive immediately, what income remains with the transferor and who bears costs later? The tax assessment, a compensation between children and a possible mandatory part supplement are based on different rules. A sum specified in the contract therefore does not automatically decide all three questions.
| Document | What can be clarified with it |
|---|---|
| Contract and subsequent amendments | Find consideration, obligations and reservations |
| Account statements or proof of ownership | Prove the date and extent of enforcement |
| Dispositions for both parents | The righteousness of the reward. |
Question on this subject · Anticipated succession
Money claim, donation and economic value
The legal examination separates the allocation of assets from a possible monetary settlement. In the case of lifetime transfers, consideration, reserved rights and enforcement date shall be disclosed. An arrangement for crediting to the compulsory share and compensation among descendants have different prerequisites and can lead to different results.
In international succession cases, the status of inheritance also covers in principle compulsory share rights as well as the compensation and crediting of previous grants (Art.) 23, par. 2 letters h and i of the EU Heritage Regulation. Whether the property was effectively transferred during his lifetime can be governed by other regulations.
Interaction of legal areas at a glance · EU Marriage Property Regulation
Six examples from inheritance law practice
‘Loan’ is included in the intended use
Case 1. Determine the repayment agreement.
Loan borrowers, backup providers and owners can be different people. At the date of death, residual debt, existing collateral and ongoing installments are determined. Only then can it be identified who the creditor can claim in which capacity.
One instalment has been repaid
Case 2. That speaks for guilt.
The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.
A gift was only promised.
Case 3. Examine form and execution.
Donation promises, actual performance and any consideration are documented separately. It is important to know which asset advantage the beneficiary actually received and whether the participants had already agreed on a later crediting at the time of the grant.
Mother pays tuition costs
Case 4. Determine the purpose of maintenance.
The envisaged benefit shall be ranked by obligor, recipient, start and maturity. The economic classification must also take into account adjustment, protection and the consequences of a previous death of a person involved.
The father transfers a property
Case 5. Use the notary deed.
For the examination, the complete document including annexes and subsequent supplements shall be procured. A draft, a certified signature and a fully certified contract document different processes.
A person entitled to a compulsory share asks for payment
Case 6. Check the donation in the list.
The starting point is the marital status on the day of death and the statutory comparison rate. For quantification purposes, estate values, deductible liabilities and possible previous grants are recognised separately. In this way, it remains clear at which position the participants set different amounts.
