Two BGH judgments 2025 on compulsory share and legacy

The Federal Court of Justice has clarified in two decisions which knowledge counts for the mandatory part of a child and how a donation to a treating doctor is to be assessed.

Paternity and limitations

In the judgment of 12. March 2025 (IV ZR 88/24) separates the BGH emergence and start of regular limitation. Entitlement to a compulsory share arises with the succession. For the knowledge according to § 199 Abs. 1 No 2 BGB also counts in the case of a non-marital child the knowledge of the effective recognition or legally binding judicial determination of paternity. Grossly negligent ignorance shall be assessed separately. Judgment IV ZR 88/24

Benefit to the treating physician

On 2 January In July 2025, the BGH (IV ZR 93/24) ruled that the prohibition of professional donation for the doctor in the event of a dispute did not render the legacy suspended in his favor ineffective via § 134 BGB. Other reasons for ineffectiveness shall be independently assessed. Decision-making meeting at Leibniz University Hannover

Six practical examples

A daughter learns of the inheritance

In addition, her knowledge of the legal father must be determined.

The daughter submits judicial communications, documents of descent and her previous correspondence chronologically. The time of death and the time when she knew the circumstances giving rise to the claim may fall apart.

There is an acknowledgement

Document the time of its effectiveness and knowledge.

It must be clarified whether the recognition has become legally effective, which consents were available and when the daughter found out about it. The date of signature alone does not answer these questions.

A judgment shall be valid:

Secure the date and access of the decision.

The family procures the decision with legal force note and proves when the person concerned found out about her. Only then can the time classification for the limitation test be carried out.

A patient considers her family doctor

Examine the legacy based on the concrete ban.

The will is compared with the rule relevant to the doctor. It is crucial to whom the ban is addressed and which legal consequence for the patient's disposition actually follows.

There are indications of a threat

These are to be investigated independently of professional law.

Whoever claims the influence, records wording, place, time and witnesses. Medical treatment alone does not constitute a threat or cause of disposition.

A Legacy is Effective

For the fulfillment, the object and the complained inheritance must be determined.

Before fulfillment, it must be clarified whether the named right still belongs to the estate and who is complained as heir. The beneficiary must assert his claim against the correct debtor.

Parenting · Obligatory shareholding

Related legal guide · German certificate of inheritance