Practical Archive · November 2025 · Editorial Processing November 2026
A niece vacated the apartment on the assumption that she had inherited alone. A younger testament calls the nephew. The dispute now concerns original items, proceeds from the sale and possible expenses. An orderly directory at the time of eviction is valuable to both sides.
Legal classification
Anyone who obtains something from the inheritance on the basis of a law of inheritance that is actually not due to him can be the owner of the inheritance. The true inheritance can demand publication and, under certain conditions, information about existence and whereabouts.
Own heir, claimed inheritance right of the owner and the individual objects occupy. Uses, replacements and uses are to be charged separately.
Six case variants
A later will displaces the first
Case 1. Examine the delivery of objects.
The items are determined on the basis of an inventory list with the previous owner. Then it is checked whether he obtained as an alleged heir and which proceeds or substitute items are still available.
The supposed inheritance sells a picture
Case 2. Pursue the proceeds.
For the negotiation, proceeds, costs and existing charges are calculated separately. Before a binding commitment, the parties concerned clarify whose participation is necessary and what alternative exists if the agreement fails.
Rents were collected
Case 3. Require usage billing.
The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.
A repair was paid for
Case 4. Testing of use substitutes.
The pedigree is played through for both possible death sequences. In the case of each vacant position, it must be noted whether the wording designates a specific substitute or whether the solution has to be determined first by interpretation and legal rules.
A third party is merely a custodian.
Case 5. Examine other claims bases.
Anyone who keeps only a key or piece of furniture for the family does not already claim his own right of inheritance. Ownership, possession and contractual claims are therefore to be distinguished in accordance with the actual property.
Documentation missing
Case 6. Consider information according to § 2027 BGB.
The heir shall indicate the missing estate and the circumstances which may give rise to an obligation to provide information. In this way, a specific inventory information can be requested and later checked for completeness.
