Promises of gifts

A gift promise on the condition that the recipient survives the donor is in principle subject to the regulations on dispositions of death. If the donation has already been made, apply according to § 2301 Abs. 2 The Rules Among the Living.

What form applies to a gift that is supposed to work only after death?

What matters is survival condition, timing and execution. Whether possession, property or merely an instruction have been transferred is to be determined on the basis of concrete documents.

What makes a difference in individual cases

Examine exactly what was done before death. A promised amount of money, an irrevocably executed payment and a merely prepared bank form can have completely different consequences. The timing often decides more than the heading “gift” on a private document.

Symbolic image of an estate property in Lower Saxony

Checking the transfer contract on the basis of everyday life

Work through the agreed services in time order. What does the beneficiary receive immediately, what income remains with the transferor and who bears costs later? The tax assessment, a compensation between children and a possible mandatory part supplement are based on different rules. A sum specified in the contract therefore does not automatically decide all three questions.

DocumentWhat can be clarified with it
Contract and subsequent amendmentsFind consideration, obligations and reservations
Account statements or proof of ownershipProve the date and extent of enforcement
Dispositions for both parentsThe righteousness of the reward.

Question on this subject · Anticipated succession

Money claim, donation and economic value

The legal examination separates the allocation of assets from a possible monetary settlement. In the case of lifetime transfers, consideration, reserved rights and enforcement date shall be disclosed. An arrangement for crediting to the compulsory share and compensation among descendants have different prerequisites and can lead to different results.

In international succession cases, the status of inheritance also covers in principle compulsory share rights as well as the compensation and crediting of previous grants (Art.) 23, par. 2 letters h and i of the EU Heritage Regulation. Whether the property was effectively transferred during his lifetime can be governed by other regulations.

Interaction of legal areas at a glance · EU Marriage Property Regulation

Six examples from inheritance law practice

The father promises only verbally a ring for the death

Case 1. Check the form.

If the recipient is to receive the ring only if he survives the father, the distinction between donation and death is important. A mere oral announcement does not reliably ensure the later handover.

The ring is transferred immediately

Case 2. Enforcement documentation.

The participants document whether ownership and possession should already pass on in life. Whoever merely keeps the ring until death is in a different position than the final acquirer.

A deposit remains with the donor

Case 3. Clarify the power of disposal.

Contract, custodianship and restrictions on disposition show whether the recipient had a legally secured position during his lifetime. An internal desire of the donor alone does not prove a completed transition.

The payout is merely deferred

Case 4. Defining the survival condition.

A nominally identical payment can be economically different. For the negotiation, amount, maturity, interest and collateral are compared. In the case of an installment solution, the failure of a rate also belongs in the agreement.

A banking contract benefits third parties

Case 5. Examine the contract model.

Contract holders and only authorised representatives are distinguished on the basis of bank documents. Subsequently, the creditor requests the status on the relevant date and, where necessary, evidence of subsequent movements. In this way, the existence and later provisions remain to be distinguished.

The gifted person dies first

Case 6. Read condition and substitute rule.

The pedigree is played through for both possible death sequences. In the case of each vacant position, it must be noted whether the wording designates a specific substitute or whether the solution has to be determined first by interpretation and legal rules.

Legal basis and advice

§ 2301 BGB · Addressing inheritance law