In order to comprehensively regulate an inheritance, a decedent has several options for arranging the legal protection of his estate. In the following, the various alternatives, tax aspects with examples and relevant case law are explained.
1. Possibilities of the estate scheme
A decedent can arrange the distribution of his property by legal, testamentary or contractual provisions:
a) Legal succession
If there is no will or inheritance contract, the legal succession shall take place in accordance with §§ 1924 ff. BGB:
- Heirs of first orderChildren and grandchildren (§ 1924 BGB).
- Second order heirsParents, siblings (§ 1925 BGB).
- Heirs of third orderGrandparents, uncles, aunts (§ 1926 BGB).
b. Will
The deceased can determine his last will by a will in accordance with §§ 1937, 2229 BGB. Types of Wills:
- Own will (§ 2247 BGB): Must be written and signed completely by hand.
- Notarized Testament (§ 2232 BGB): Is declared and certified before a notary.
c. Contract of succession
An inheritance contract (§§ 1941, 2274 ff.) BGB) is a notarized contract by which the deceased bindingly regulates parts of his estate. Especially suitable for entrepreneurs or partners without a marriage contract.
d) Capital transfers during life
- Donation under conditions (§ 516 ff.) BGB: A donation during your lifetime can reduce the estate and at the same time be tax-advantageous.
- Utility or residence: The decedent can transfer assets and reserve rights such as a right of residence (§§ 1093, 1030 BGB).
2. Tax aspects of inheritances
The succession is subject to inheritance tax according to the Inheritance Tax and Gift Tax Act (ErbStG). The amount of the tax shall be determined by reference to the degree of kinship, the value of the estate and the allowances.
a) Exemptions (§ 16 ErbStG)
- Spouse/partner: 500.000 €
- Children: 400,000 €
- Grandchildren: €200,000
- Others: €20,000
b) Tax classes and tax rates (§ 19 ErbStG)
- Category Ispouses, children (7–30 %)
- Category II: siblings, nieces/nephews (15–43%)
- Category III: Foreigners (30–50%)
c. Examples
- Example 1: Spouse inherits € 600,000. After deducting the allowance of €500,000, a taxable inheritance of €100,000 remains. For class I, the tax rate is 11 %. The tax is € 11,000.
- Example 2A nephew inherits €300,000. Allowance: €20,000. Taxable amount: €280,000. Tax Class II (20%): Tax load is €56,000.
d Tax optimisation
- Donations during your lifetime (tax-free possible every 10 years, § 14 ErbStG).
- use of allowances by usufruct models or advance capital transfers.
3. Important jurisprudence
Relevant judgments often clarify disputes about compulsory share rights, tax optimizations or formal requirements:
- Formal requirements for a will:
- BGH, decision of 27. September 2017 – IV ZB 15/16Confirms the validity of a will by hand, provided that it is readable and written by hand.
- Compulsory supplementary rights:
- BGH, judgment of 23. October 2019 – IV ZR 124/18: Clarifies that donations within the last 10 years are to be taken into account pro rata for compulsory share supplement entitlements.
- Inheritance tax and business succession:
- BVerfG, Judgment of 17. December 2014 – 1 BvL 21/12Inheritance tax privileges for company successions (violation of the principle of equality, reform of § 13a ErbStG).
- Contract of succession and challenge:
- BGH, judgment of 13. January 2021 – IV ZR 231/19Then, the beneficiary will have to contest the lawfulness of the beneficiary.
4. Succession right
The discount control offers a wide variety of design possibilities. A will or inheritance contract creates clarity, while tax optimizations can relieve the estate economically. In view of the complex legal situation and tax regulations, early advice by a notary or lawyer is recommended.
Six case variants for practice
The daughter should be the sole heir.
Case 1. Explicitly declare the establishment of an inheritance.
For the assessment, the family circumstances on the relevant day and the full text of existing dispositions shall be recorded. Only from both can it be deduced in which legal position the family member can act or demand something.
The nephew only gets a picture
Case 2. Formulate the legacy.
The wording must show who is to demand the service and who is to provide it. Subsequently, the specific object, its availability and the time of performance are determined. This is especially important if several heirs manage the estate together.
Two children are to inherit the same
Case 3. Rules on home allocation and value balance.
For the solution, ownership and encumbrances are taken at the relevant time. Anyone who owns the key or bears ongoing costs is not necessarily the owner. This distinction affects the value and possible dispositions.
A daughter has died.
Case 4. Determine a replacement for their tribe.
The pedigree is played through for both possible death sequences. In the case of each vacant position, it must be noted whether the wording designates a specific substitute or whether the solution has to be determined first by interpretation and legal rules.
Spouses want to bond
Case 5. Changeability and change reservations.
All versions shall be ordered in chronological order with date and signature. The test shall be carried out for each individual arrangement. A later change may affect a property, while an earlier binding inheritance continues for other issues.
A German lives in Spain
Case 6. Examine the choice of law in the will.
The family shall submit all decisions with the date of establishment and proof of nationality. It is necessary to check which right denotes the specific clause and whether it covers the succession. International competence is examined separately.
