Contesting or interpreting a will

An unusual result does not make a will in itself contestable. First, it must be checked what the decree of the decedent has been effective in form. Only then does the question of a serious error, a threat or the passing over of a person entitled to a compulsory share arise.

The next steps

The challenge pursuant to §§ 2078 ff. BGB requires a legal reason and a person entitled to challenge. In the case of the dispositions referred to in § 2081 BGB, the declaration must be made to the probate court. The annual period shall in principle depend on the knowledge of the ground for appeal. Doubts about testability or authenticity must be distinguished from this.

What makes a difference in individual cases

Before the family commissions an opinion, the dispute should be established. A forged signature requires other evidence than a mistake about a beneficiary. Recipients of declarations, authorization and deadline also depend on which legal complaint is actually pursued.

Symbolic image for family estate planning

Separate allegation, evidence and procedural objective

A helpful case chronology distinguishes one’s own perception, communication of another person and mere conclusion. Next to each crucial date, write down which document or witness can say something about it. It should be established before any cost of appraisal is incurred whether it is necessary to clarify the issue of heirs, the effectiveness of a declaration or the issue of a specific value.

DocumentWhat can be clarified with it
Original documents and findsCheck authenticity, completeness and chronological order
Dated News and WitnessesAssigning concrete facts and source of perception
Court letters and proof of deliverySecuring time limits and subject matter of the procedure

Question on this subject · Probate court

Form, content and binding of an order

Three questions are separated during the evaluation. Has the declaration been formally established? What does it mean for the specifically designated person or thing? And was the decree-holder bound by an earlier order? For the answer, all versions are arranged chronologically and the family conditions at the respective time of construction are reconstructed.

Art. 24 to 27 EU Heritage Regulation distinguish, among other things, between the material validity of a disposition, inheritance contracts and the form of written dispositions. In the case of wills, the Hague Form of Testament Convention may also be relevant. Formal effectiveness alone answers neither the hereditary quota nor the question of later modifiability.

Interaction of legal areas at a glance · 1961 Hague Convention

Six practical examples

The deceased calls the wrong street name

Case 1. Interpretation can clarify the intended subject matter.

The wording must show who is to demand the service and who is to provide it. Subsequently, the specific object, its availability and the time of performance are determined. This is especially important if several heirs manage the estate together.

A son threatened with a sensitive evil

Case 2. Determine the cause of the threat.

The person concerned notes what action was announced, who was there and when the will came into being. Only this temporal relationship allows to assess whether the order would have had the same content even without the influence.

After construction, a child is born

Case 3. Examine knowledge and hypothetical will according to § 2079 BGB.

For the time-limit verification, the event, access and knowledge with date shall be recorded separately. Envelope, judicial notification or receipt can be decisive here. It is then necessary to determine which action must be received in good time and at which point.

The signature is foreign

Case 4. Authenticity is a question of effectiveness.

The original shall be secured. A copy can only reveal the rows, subsequent additions and the position of the signature to a limited extent. Comparative writings from the same time and the circumstances of storage help to narrow down open questions of fact.

A family member does not benefit from the removal

Case 5. Clarification of eligibility separately.

One plays through the omission of the attacked arrangement. If the same other inheritance were to benefit, the relative lacks the immediate advantage necessary for his own challenge.

A heritage knows the reason for months

Case 6. Calculate the deadline and correct receiving agency.

For the time-limit verification, the event, access and knowledge with date shall be recorded separately. Envelope, judicial notification or receipt can be decisive here. It is then necessary to determine which action must be received in good time and at which point.

§ 2081 BGB · Question on this subject