If the surviving spouse does not become an heir or legatee in the legal property regime, he may demand the actual compensation for profits and, under the legal conditions, the compulsory share from the non-extended inheritance. Even after waiver, § 1371 Abs. 3 BGB intervene.
What part of the obligation remains for the spouse in addition to the actual gain?
initial and final assets of both spouses, inheritance status and legacies. Before a decision is made, the deadline and both calculation paths are to be compared.
What makes a difference in individual cases
The decision often depends on assets that were present at the time of marriage. A current wealth overview is not enough for this. In the case of companies or real estate, historical values and subsequent gains must be clearly separated before the property law solution is compared with an inheritance quota.

From quota to payment amount
For the first invoice, legal inheritance quota and actual value should be in separate columns. Before each assessment, it must be clarified who the property belonged to at death. In the case of a house kept together, only the proportion of the deceased should be included. Gifts from earlier years are again their own computing variable.
| Document | What can be clarified with it |
|---|---|
| Family Tree and Marriage Contract | Determining the legal comparative rate |
| Testaments, former treaties and waivers | Determining the economic status of the beneficiary |
| List of assets with dates of death | Calculate amount and report contested positions |
Question on this subject · Inventory
Money claim, donation and economic value
The legal examination separates the allocation of assets from a possible monetary settlement. In the case of lifetime transfers, consideration, reserved rights and enforcement date shall be disclosed. An arrangement for crediting to the compulsory share and compensation among descendants have different prerequisites and can lead to different results.
In international succession cases, the status of inheritance also covers in principle compulsory share rights as well as the compensation and crediting of previous grants (Art.) 23, par. 2 letters h and i of the EU Heritage Regulation. Whether the property was effectively transferred during his lifetime can be governed by other regulations.
Interaction of legal areas at a glance · EU Marriage Property Regulation
Six examples from inheritance law practice
The surviving spouse is disinherited
Case 1. Finding actual gain.
The marriage and contract data are compared with the date of death. Only when the property status and, where applicable, the status of a divorce proceeding are established can it be determined which rights the spouse is entitled to from his own property and which ones from the succession.
A Legacy is Exposed
Case 2. Legally assess acceptance or rejection.
Reason for appeal and time of knowledge are recorded separately for each person who comes after. The family clarifies before making the declaration which court it can accept and who is acting effectively in the case of minor children.
There are two children
Case 3. Calculate non-increased spouse rate.
The invoice begins with the family constellation and the assets relevant for the comparison. The participants record the calculation path with fractions before converting into money. In this way, errors in quota and value can be identified separately.
There is a marriage contract
Case 4. Preliminary identification of the property regime.
The marriage and contract data are compared with the date of death. Only when the property status and, where applicable, the status of a divorce proceeding are established can it be determined which rights the spouse is entitled to from his own property and which ones from the succession.
Initial ability is unknown
Case 5. Secure bank receipts and property values.
Contract holders and only authorised representatives are distinguished on the basis of bank documents. Subsequently, the creditor requests the status on the relevant date and, where necessary, evidence of subsequent movements. In this way, the existence and later provisions remain to be distinguished.
A deviation is considered
Case 6. Secure the deadline before final assessment.
For a robust outcome, the measurement date and condition of the asset are determined. If the parties concerned differ in value, they should first compare the underlying data before negotiating the compensation amount.
