Replacement power

A substitution power may allow the complainant to perform a particular performance by another. Whether an electoral legacy or a major achievement is meant by the right of replacement follows from the interpretation.

Can money be paid instead of the bequeathed object?

Valuation date, valuation, deadline for declaration and cancellation of an item should be regulated in the will.

What makes a difference in individual cases

If an amount of money is allowed instead of the thing, its calculation must also work. In the case of a securities depository, the value varies between death, acceptance and delivery. A clear deadline and a named evaluation source avoid that the replacement service itself becomes the main dispute of the family.

Symbolic image for family estate planning

Then, they will be able to fulfill the promise.

Name the person who has to perform and the one who can demand the performance. For an item, separate the time of claim from the later surrender or rewrite. If a monetary value is to be able to replace the object, it must be traceable who decides this and how the value can be determined.

DocumentWhat can be clarified with it
Original of the decisionDetermine beneficiaries and complainants
Proof of holding or ownershipExamination of the existence and classification of the object
Reference date and surrender documentRecord value, maturity and performance

Question on this subject · Legacy

Form, content and binding of an order

Three questions are separated during the evaluation. Has the declaration been formally established? What does it mean for the specifically designated person or thing? And was the decree-holder bound by an earlier order? For the answer, all versions are arranged chronologically and the family conditions at the respective time of construction are reconstructed.

Art. 24 to 27 EU Heritage Regulation distinguish, among other things, between the material validity of a disposition, inheritance contracts and the form of written dispositions. In the case of wills, the Hague Form of Testament Convention may also be relevant. Formal effectiveness alone answers neither the hereditary quota nor the question of later modifiability.

Interaction of legal areas at a glance · 1961 Hague Convention

Six examples from inheritance law practice

A car may be replaced by money

Case 1. Determine the value date.

The heirs determine on the basis of the will whether the value should be decisive at death, selection or fulfillment. Especially in the case of a rapid loss of value, this question can significantly change the amount of money owed.

Two paintings are called equal

Case 2. Checking the electoral legacy.

The wording must show who is to demand the service and who is to provide it. Subsequently, the specific object, its availability and the time of performance are determined. This is especially important if several heirs manage the estate together.

The replacement amount is fixed

Case 3. Read the text for adaptation.

The pedigree is played through for both possible death sequences. In the case of each vacant position, it must be noted whether the wording designates a specific substitute or whether the solution has to be determined first by interpretation and legal rules.

The car went down.

Case 4. Clarify the distribution of risks.

The hereditary quota is distinguished from the allocation of individual objects. For an agreement, the outstanding debts and costs are first recorded and then takeover, compensation and execution are coordinated in a joint agreement.

Election period expires

Case 5. interpretation of the law.

For the time-limit verification, the event, access and knowledge with date shall be recorded separately. Envelope, judicial notification or receipt can be decisive here. It is then necessary to determine which action must be received in good time and at which point.

The inheritance pays partly

Case 6. Determine the fulfillment effect.

The recipient confirms the amount and purpose of the instalment. If the benefit is only referred to as a discount, it must be checked separately whether a waiver or a final agreement has also been agreed.

Legal basis and advice

§ 2174 BGB · Addressing inheritance law