Deficient speech

If neither estate administration nor estate insolvency can be carried out due to lack of assets, the heir may refuse satisfaction under the conditions of § 1990 BGB, if the estate is not sufficient. Existing estate is to be given for satisfaction.

What happens if the estate does not even cover the costs of the proceedings?

The lack of mass must be explained in a comprehensible manner. The inventory in the event of succession, subsequent proceeds, payments and items that still exist must be documented.

What makes a difference in individual cases

The claim “there is nothing left” is difficult to judge without a comprehensible calculation. Compare the stock on the death day with all subsequent proceeds and payments. This makes it clear which estate still exists and whether an object can be issued for the satisfaction of the creditor.

Symbolic image of an estate property in Lower Saxony

Securitisation of assets and liabilities separately

Create both a wealth balance sheet and a list of next payment dates. A property that has not yet been sold can be worthwhile, while immediately due receivables remain uncovered. Differentiation must be made between inherited debts, expenses of the estate and new personal obligations of the heir. The date on which reliable information was available also belongs in the file.

DocumentWhat can be clarified with it
Bank balances and ownership documentsSeparating Available Money from Long-Term Values
Claims and maturitiesDetermine the time of a possible need for action
Evidence of own expensesDifferentiating between estate and private assets

Question on this subject · Insolvency of the estate

Legacy, liabilities and personal liability

For each liability asserted, it must be clarified when it arose, who was originally the debtor and whether a personal obligation of the heir has been added. In the event of an uncertain asset situation, the clarification of the stock and the examination of waiver, limitation of liability or insolvency proceedings run in parallel. A statement of claims alone shall not respect a time limit.

In the case of a cross-border succession, liability for debts under the succession statute (Art.) 23, par. 2 letter g of the EU Heritage Regulation. For insolvency proceedings, separate rules apply. The state in which a deviation can be declared and the form of the declaration must also be examined independently.

Interaction of legal areas at a glance · Art. 23 EU inheritance law regulation

Six examples from inheritance law practice

The insolvency application is rejected due to lack of assets

Case 1. Secure the decision.

An asset status compares realizable values and mature claims. Uncertain claims are specifically reported. If there are concrete signs of insolvency or over-indebtedness, a possible need for action must be assessed immediately.

A car is still there

Case 2. Examine the publication for enforcement.

The installation shows the vehicle with location, condition and loads. Also in the case of a deficient plea, it must be examined to what extent the existing estate is to be issued for the satisfaction of the creditor.

Legacy has mixed accounts

Case 3. Breakdown of movements.

For each movement, the date, contra account and purpose of use are documented. A comprehensible comparison with the date of death helps to clarify which amount still belongs to the estate.

A creditor complains

Case 4. Consider objection and procedural reservation.

The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.

An unknown balance appears

Case 5. Adjust the invoice.

The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.

Out of own pocket was paid

Case 6. Expenditure reimbursement check separately.

The pedigree is played through for both possible death sequences. In the case of each vacant position, it must be noted whether the wording designates a specific substitute or whether the solution has to be determined first by interpretation and legal rules.

Legal basis and advice

§ 1990 BGB · Addressing inheritance law