The smaller inheritance can trigger an additional money claim

Practical Archive · January 2020 · Editorial Processing November 2026

According to the will of her widowed mother, two sisters inherit seven eighths and one eighth. Without a will, everyone would have conceded half. For the less considered sister, the threshold is therefore one quarter of the adjusted estate value. Their decision shall be based on the distance between that threshold and the value of their inheritance.

What counts for the decision

Those who are entitled to a compulsory share with an overly small inheritance rate can demand the missing value from the co-heirs. § 2305 BGB applies nationwide. The starting point is half of the legal hereditary quota.

Variants from practice

The daughter receives an eighth

Case 1. If their duty share is one-quarter, the value of it is one-eighth missing.

The starting point is the marital status on the day of death and the statutory comparison rate. For quantification purposes, estate values, deductible liabilities and possible previous grants are recognised separately. In this way, it remains clear at which position the participants set different amounts.

For 400,000 euros pure discount, this difference corresponds to 50,000 euros

Case 2. What are the consequences for those involved?

With a legal quota of one half, the compulsory share quota is a quarter. If the daughter receives as heiress only one eighth, are at 400,000 euros calculation basis a comparison value of 100,000 euros actually 50,000 euros.

One House Makes Up Almost All the Estate

Case 3. The monetary claim shall be determined by determining its market value.

For a robust outcome, the measurement date and condition of the asset are determined. If the parties concerned differ in value, they should first compare the underlying data before negotiating the compensation amount.

The son receives only a legacy

Case 4. For his options § 2307 BGB applies.

The wording must show who is to demand the service and who is to provide it. Subsequently, the specific object, its availability and the time of performance are determined. This is especially important if several heirs manage the estate together.

Another child is found

Case 5. This can already change the legal comparison rate.

The invoice begins with the family constellation and the assets relevant for the comparison. The participants record the calculation path with fractions before converting into money. In this way, errors in quota and value can be identified separately.

The co-heir has made a monetary payment

Case 6. Before the action is brought, it must be examined which claim has been repaid.

The hereditary quota is distinguished from the allocation of individual objects. For an agreement, the outstanding debts and costs are first recorded and then takeover, compensation and execution are coordinated in a joint agreement.

Specialist page: Additional compulsory part · Agreements on consultation

Related legal guide · Compulsory share under German law