Can the first-time recipient freely decide on the gift?

Praxisarchiv · June 2024 · Editorial processing November 2026

A grandmother transfers money to her daughter, who forwards it to the grandson the next day. The short interval alone does not answer the tax allocation. Simultaneous agreements and the actual possibility of keeping the money or using it differently are crucial evidence.

Legal classification

In the case of a transfer within the family, it must be clarified whether two independent donations exist or the intermediate recipient was obliged to forward them. Actual freedom of choice is central.

Reconstruct contracts, cash flow, chronological sequence and economic power of disposal. A certain waiting time alone does not decide the attribution.

Six case variants

The mother can keep the money

Case 1. Own power of disposal speaks for separate acquisitions.

If the mother was able to keep the donation, use it elsewhere or choose another recipient, this speaks for her own freedom of choice. Proofs of order and actual transfer shall be kept together.

The document shall oblige the disclosure of:

Case 2. Check direct attribution.

The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.

Both contracts are made on the same day

Case 3. Determine overall circumstances.

The close chronological sequence is an indication, but does not decide alone. It has to be checked whether the first recipient was already legally or actually obliged to pass on in advance.

The money never reaches the intermediate purchaser

Case 4. Clarification of the payment order.

The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.

There are side agreements.

Case 5. Evaluate them as well.

In addition to the notarial text, e-mails, payment instructions and oral agreements are determined. You can show whether a seemingly freely available donation actually depended on a forwarding.

Previous gifts are available

Case 6. Calculate allowances per employment relationship.

Donation promises, actual performance and any consideration are documented separately. It is important to know which asset advantage the beneficiary actually received and whether the participants had already agreed on a later crediting at the time of the grant.

Recess: chain yaw

Related legal guide · Donation