As of November 2026
A house burdened with a right of residence is valued as a freely available object. The beneficiary lived there on the day of death.
What matters in this case
Have the scope, existence and economic significance of the law checked as of the deadline. Only then is a comparison with unloaded objects meaningful.
For a beneficiary of the compulsory share who is not heir, information and valuation are separate steps on the way to payment. A directory can look complete and still contain an open evaluation question.
A related constellation
Is the offer price already the property value – The family sets in the estate register the desired price of a realtor. A sale has not yet been made. Clarify the valuation date, condition and basis for comparison. An offer may be an indication, but it does not replace a viable valuation in every constellation.
Mandatory Participation Law with Further Practice Cases · § 2314 BGB in the wording
Further practical cases for comparison
A child should refrain from providing information
Before disbursing an amount, the daughter shall confirm that she does not request any further information. Information on previous donations is missing. Before signing, clarify which claims should be settled. A waiver of further information can make the later checking of previously unknown values practically more difficult.
The daughter only gets called a fortune sum
The sole heir specifies a total amount, but does not provide a list. A condo known to the daughter does not appear in his message. Ask for information on the types of assets and liabilities. A reliable compulsory share account requires traceable individual headings.
The depot has lost its value since death
Shortly after the fall of inheritance, share prices decline. In the calculation, the heir uses the current deposit values. Request course and inventory evidence for the day of death. Subsequent decisions by the heir about holding or selling are to be distinguished from the reference date value.
The brother blames his care time.
For years, the brother took care of his mother. Now he deducts a self-appraised hourly wage from the estate. Check a contractual remuneration and a possible legal compensation separately. The hours worked do not prove for themselves a due estate debt.
Related legal guide · Compulsory share under German law
