The gift remains first a promise

As of November 2026

A grandmother announces a payment in writing, but does not transfer anything.

What matters in this case

The form, the willingness to commit and any subsequent execution shall be examined.

A gift requires an agreement on gratuitousness. If at the same time a consideration is accepted, the parties must be able to prove the content, scope and actual implementation of the agreement.

A related constellation

Was the money only intended for setting up a practice – The parents transfer money for a practice, the son buys securities from it. Check if there was a mere motive, binding condition or other agreement.

Donation with further practical cases · § 516 BGB in the wording

Further practical cases for comparison

The return of the gift is agreed

When the child dies, the property will fall back. The exact trigger and the type of backup will determine whether parents reach the goal vis-à-vis third parties.

A gift should count on the compulsory share

A transfer is not called eligible until years later. For the examination, it is particularly important what was determined in the original grant and communicated to the recipient.

Transfer from the joint account of parents

The daughter considers both parents to be equally large donors. Account origin, ownership of funds and declarations by the parties involved may give a different allocation.

The daughter takes care of

In the handover contract there is a care obligation without specifying hours. For the valuation, the services owed and their actual performance must be determined separately.