Who decides in the community of heirs about repairs?

Practical Archive · June 2026 · Editorial Processing November 2026

A pipe break requires immediate safety at the weekend. The comprehensive modernization of the bath, on the other hand, can wait until the vote of the heirs. Separate orders and invoices later make it clear which costs were part of the acute maintenance and which were part of the planned improvement.

Legal classification

Several heirs manage the undivided estate jointly. Required conservation measures, proper management and orders are subject to different conditions. Vote weight may depend on hereditary quotas.

For each measure, state the purpose, urgency, economic importance and costs. An administrative decision does not readily replace participation in an order.

Six case variants

A water pipe bursts

Case 1. Proceed immediately.

The heir first commissions the security required for damage prevention and documents the condition. For a comprehensive renovation, the financing and necessary participation of the other heirs must subsequently be clarified.

The roof should be luxuriously extended

Case 2. Examine consent requirements.

An extension to an additional apartment can significantly change the value and use of the house. Before commissioning, therefore, decision-making, approval and financing must be distinguished from a mere repair.

The apartment is rented

Case 3. Assess proper administration.

For the solution, ownership and encumbrances are taken at the relevant time. Anyone who owns the key or bears ongoing costs is not necessarily the owner. This distinction affects the value and possible dispositions.

A house should be sold

Case 4. Vote on the property.

For the negotiation, proceeds, costs and existing charges are calculated separately. Before a binding commitment, the parties concerned clarify whose participation is necessary and what alternative exists if the agreement fails.

An inheritance alone bears costs

Case 5. Documenting compensation.

Invoices, payment receipts and agreements are kept. Whether the other inheritance has to be reimbursed pro rata depends, inter alia, on the purpose, urgency and classification of the measure.

Rental receipts are in private accounts

Case 6. Require accounting.

The claim shall be broken down by creditor, legal ground, amount and maturity. In the case of payments already made, the date and purpose must be added. In this way, it is possible to determine which part is still open and which is actually in dispute.

Deepening: community of heirs