Who can choose between two bequeathed objects?

Praxisarchiv · April 2021 · Editorial processing November 2026

Two violins are mentioned as a selection, but one has now been awarded. Before the heir claims that the instrument is no longer available, he clarifies property and right of return from the loan contract. Spatial absence is different from a previous sale.

Legal classification

An elective legacy leaves the performance item open at first. In case of doubt, the choice is for the complainant. The deceased may assign it to the person concerned or to a third party.

Clearly identify objects, record voting rights and substitute regulations. Especially in the case of collections, an illustrated list avoids dispute over the selection.

Six case variants

Two paintings are named

Case 1. One thing has to be done.

Both paintings are identified by artist, motif and location. Once the selection has been made, exactly the selected work is indicated in the handover protocol.

The niece should choose

Case 2. Their declaration shall be documented.

The niece explains to the right recipient which piece she chooses. A clear designation prevents a non-binding visit from later being understood as an exercised choice.

The Testament is silent

Case 3. The legal rule of doubt applies.

First of all, it is to be determined by interpretation whether the will assigns the right to vote to a particular person. If this remains open, the statutory assignment of the right to vote is used.

A picture is sold

Case 4. The consequences depend on the decision.

For the negotiation, proceeds, costs and existing charges are calculated separately. Before a binding commitment, the parties concerned clarify whose participation is necessary and what alternative exists if the agreement fails.

A third party should decide

Case 5. Its accessibility must be clarified early.

The heirs clarify whether the third is still alive and wants to take over the destiny. In the event of its failure, it is examined which substitute rule provides for the order or law.

Both heirs argue about value

Case 6. A difference in value alone does not change the selection rule.

Both works are assessed separately. The higher market value alone does not allow one party to assume an electoral power effectively assigned to the other.

Deepening: Electoral Legacy

Related legal guide · Legacy