Practical Archive · March 2025 · Editorial Processing November 2026
A German and an Italian national live as a couple alternately in Hanover and Florence. For each spouse, the subsequent succession must be independently checked. A common property and a common address do not make a personal choice of law and the prior question of property law superfluous.
Legal classification
For succession from 17 onwards. In August 2015, the EU inheritance law regulation basically links to the last habitual residence. A choice of law in favour of the right of one's own nationality, whether express or resulting from a disposition, may change the outcome. An obviously closer connection is only exceptionally decisive.
Examine jurisdiction and applicable law separately. Denmark and Ireland do not participate in the regulation. Tax law, matrimonial property law and enforcement of registers require their own audits. The Regulation may also invoke the law of a third country.
Six case variants
A German living permanently in Lyon
Case 1. French inheritance law can apply despite a German passport.
The German passport is sufficient as a link for a possible choice of law. Without such a choice, the actual centre of life in Lyon and any exception to the principle of residence shall be examined.
An Italian in Hanover effectively elects Italian law
Case 2. This does not automatically change jurisdiction.
The heirs separately examine which court conducts the proceedings and according to which substantive rules it decides. A German court may have to apply Italian inheritance law.
A German owns a holiday home in Mallorca
Case 3. The location alone does not determine their entire hereditary statute.
For the solution, ownership and encumbrances are taken at the relevant time. Anyone who owns the key or bears ongoing costs is not necessarily the owner. This distinction affects the value and possible dispositions.
The deceased commuted between Vienna and Hanover
Case 4. Family, work and residence form the overall picture.
For both places, the living situation, duration of stays and personal ties are compared. The mere number of overnight stays cannot replace the overall picture.
An account is located in Dublin
Case 5. Recognition and banking requirements must be assessed separately.
Contract holders and only authorised representatives are distinguished on the basis of bank documents. Subsequently, the creditor requests the status on the relevant date and, where necessary, evidence of subsequent movements. In this way, the existence and later provisions remain to be distinguished.
A US property belongs to the estate
Case 6. State proceedings and property law may require additional steps.
The specific procedural objective shall be identified first. Proof of inheritance and a payment order solve different problems. For this purpose, the last letter, its access and the supporting documents required for the respective request are compiled.
