Praxisarchiv · August 2022 · Editorial processing November 2026
The grandmother bequeathed the daughter a watch, which should later get to the granddaughter. If the watch is lost during the lifetime of the daughter, it must be clarified whether a replacement benefit, an insurance proceeds or just this piece was meant. A photo and a clear substitute rule make the will comprehensible.
Legal classification
If an object initially bequeathed is later to a further person, a subsequent legacy comes into consideration. For a “back-legacy” is always the concrete wording decisive.
First considered, other entitled persons, determine the time and handling of sale or loss. Property and debt rights must be distinguished.
Six case variants
A ring is supposed to become a granddaughter after the aunt's death
Case 1. Examination of the legacy.
The wording must show who is to demand the service and who is to provide it. Subsequently, the specific object, its availability and the time of performance are determined. This is especially important if several heirs manage the estate together.
The aunt sells the ring.
Case 2. Substitution and liability.
The pedigree is played through for both possible death sequences. In the case of each vacant position, it must be noted whether the wording designates a specific substitute or whether the solution has to be determined first by interpretation and legal rules.
The granddaughter dies first
Case 3. Search for replacement beneficiaries.
For the assessment, the family circumstances on the relevant day and the full text of existing dispositions shall be recorded. Only from both can it be deduced in which legal position the family member can act or demand something.
A relapse is only provided for childlessness
Case 4. Clarify the condition.
For the assessment, the family circumstances on the relevant day and the full text of existing dispositions shall be recorded. Only from both can it be deduced in which legal position the family member can act or demand something.
Instead of the ring, there is a proceeds
Case 5. Examine surrogation.
It clarifies who sold the ring, when the purchase price flowed and whether the disposition should also record a replacement. The fact that there is still money does not answer this question of interpretation alone.
A family branch is unclearly designated
Case 6. The beneficiaries shall be determined by interpretation.
The marital status and language used by the decedent help to determine the group of people meant by “family of my sister”. Each eligible person should be listed with their possible quota.
Related legal guide · Legacy
