The library is bequeathed, so are the pictures?

As of November 2026

The patent daughter is to receive "my library". Between the books hang valuable graphics that the decedent has collected.

What matters in this case

Place wording, spatial allocation and previous inventory lists side by side. A donation of the book collection does not necessarily record all objects in the room.

Under German law, the legacy basically establishes a claim against the complainant. The performance must be duly determined by the beneficiary, subject matter and contribution due.

A related constellation

The niece should choose from two pictures Both paintings are still in the house of the heiress. The niece expresses a non-binding preference during the visit. Before handing over, clarify who is entitled to the right to vote and whether it has already been exercised in a binding manner. Capture the motif, artist and condition of the chosen piece.

Legacy with further practical cases · § 2174 BGB in wording

Further practical cases for comparison

Who transports the wing?

The bequeathed concert grand piano is on the third floor. The beneficiary and the heirs argue about expansion and forwarding costs. First, determine the owed performance and the location of performance. Handover, pick-up and cost assumption can then be recorded in a written schedule.

The bequeathed savings book was rewritten

A bank has transferred the designated savings book into another product. The amount can be traced on the basis of the extracts. Reconstruct the rebooking. For the interpretation, it is important whether only the specific account or the assets invested on it should be turned.

The money legacy is due later.

The deceased wanted to give the grandson money at the training degree. Whether this time determines only the payment or already the acquisition, is open. Read the clause also in case of a discontinuation or an earlier death. Only this counter-test shows the economic importance of the formulation.

An object is only half owned

The mother bequeathed a holiday apartment to the girlfriend. According to the land registry documents, the other half already belongs to the daughter. Clarify the actual scope of ownership and the recognizable will of the mother. A claim to the procuring of third-party property requires a separate interpretation.